ArvadaCOPlumber.com is a free referral service. We are not a plumbing company. Our call line is not open yet. When it opens, calls will be answered by an independent local company in our partner network.

Water Heater Repair in Arvada, CO

In most Arvada houses the water heater lives in the basement or a utility room, out of sight until it stops working or a puddle appears. Either way, a few safe steps first, then a call.

Leaking: do this first

  1. Gas smell? Leave the house, then call 911 and Xcel Energy at 800-895-2999. Don't touch switches or the heater's controls (Xcel).
  2. Close the cold-water valve on the pipe into the top of the heater. If it won't turn, close the house's main valve (how).
  3. Cut the heat. Electric: breaker off. Gas: knob to "pilot" or "vacation".
  4. Find the source. A drip at a fitting on top is often a small repair. Water from the pipe on the side (the relief valve line) means the heater is letting off pressure or heat: call a plumber now, and keep clear of hot water coming from that pipe. Water from the tank body itself means replacement.

No hot water

For electric heaters, check the breaker. Reset it once; if it trips again, leave it off and call a plumber. For gas heaters, the pilot may be out. A pilot that won't stay lit is a job for a plumber; if you smell gas at any point, leave and call 911 and Xcel Energy at 800-895-2999.

Repair or replace?

JobNational price range
Water heater repair$150 to $1,200 (Fixr)
Gas tank heater replacedabout $1,900 on average; most pay $1,000 to $2,700 (Fixr)
Electric tank heater replaced$800 to $1,500; about $1,000 on average (Fixr)
Tankless heater installedabout $2,811 on average; $2,500 to $4,500 (Fixr)

A leaking tank is a replacement. A bad thermostat, element, igniter or valve is usually a repair. If the heater is getting old and the repair is a big share of a new one, ask for both prices side by side.

Permits and licenses

Colorado's State Plumbing Board says a plumbing contractor must take out the permits for its own work and must not work under a homeowner's permit or another company's (state board). When you get a quote for a new heater, ask whether a permit is needed for your job and whether the price includes it. Then check the company's license on the state's lookup (DORA). Gas heaters also involve a gas connection and venting, which is one more reason to want a licensed plumber.

Freezing weather and water heaters

A heater in an unheated garage or crawlspace shares the same freeze risk as the pipes around it. Denver Water's advice for cold snaps, insulating pipes in unheated spaces and keeping warm air moving to them, applies here too (Denver Water).

Questions to ask

Related pages

Sources

Last checked: November 2026.